Understanding Debt Service Coverage Ratio (DSCR) in Commercial Lending

Understanding DSCR Loans: Traditional vs. Streamlined Approaches

As someone who’s originated both types of DSCR loans, I know how important it is for brokers and borrowers to understand what’s really behind these underwriting methods.

Debt Service Coverage Ratio (DSCR) is one of the most critical ways lenders assess a property’s ability to pay its debt. But there isn’t just one way to calculate it.

Different properties, loan sizes, and borrower needs call for different approaches. Let’s break it down.

The Traditional Commercial DSCR Calculation

For large commercial deals (office, industrial, retail, multifamily, build to rent communities, and larger SFR portfolios), traditional lenders use this formula:

DSCR=Net Operating Income (NOI)/Annual Debt Service

Net Operating Income (NOI) = Gross rents – operating expenses (excluding debt service).

Annual Debt Service = Total annual principal + interest payments.

Example:

  • NOI = $1,200,000
  • Annual Debt Service = $1,000,000

DSCR=$1,200,000/$1,000,000=1.20

A DSCR of 1.20 indicates the property generates 20% more income than needed for debt payments.

Key Underwriting Standards:

  • Minimum DSCRs typically range 1.20–1.40, depending on property type, risk, and lender.
  • NOI is comprehensively underwritten, accounting for realistic income and expenses to ensure sustainable cash flow.

Typical Revenue Offsets Considered

Traditional commercial underwriting doesn’t just accept gross rent at face value—it adjusts for:

  • Vacancy Loss: A market-based factor (often 5–10%) for potential empty units.
  • Collection Loss: Accounts for late or unpaid rents.
  • Concessions / Free Rent: Discounts offered to attract tenants.
  • Miscellaneous Income Offsets: Excludes non-recurring or speculative income sources.

Typical Operating Expenses Included

Lenders also deduct necessary expenses to reflect true operating costs:

  • Property Management Fees: Even if self-managed, usually ~4–6% of effective gross income.
  • Maintenance and Repairs: Routine upkeep (excluding capital improvements).
  • Utilities (Owner-Paid): Water, sewer, electricity for common areas.
  • Insurance: Hazard and liability coverage.
  • Real Estate Taxes: Including projected reassessments.
  • Replacement Reserves: Funds set aside for capital items (roof, HVAC).
  • Administrative Costs: Accounting, legal, office expenses.
  • Janitorial / Cleaning: For common areas or commercial spaces.
  • Ground Lease Payments: If applicable.
  • Turnover Expense: If applicable
  • Other Contracted Services: Landscaping, pest control, trash removal, security.

This comprehensive approach ensures lenders evaluate real, sustainable cash flow—not just optimistic projections.

The Streamlined DSCR for Small-Balance and Private Lending

For small-balance loans, many private lenders use a streamlined DSCR approach that simplifies underwriting.

This approach is especially common for:

Single-family rental properties  
1–4 unit investment properties
Small multifamily buildings (5–8 units)
SFR portfolio loans under  $3 million

Rather than requiring detailed operating statements, these lenders focus on 
rents vs. P.I.T.A.:

DSCR=Gross Rents/P.I.T.A.

  • Gross Rents: Monthly rents, annualized for DSCR consistency.
  • P.I.T.A.: Principal, Interest, Taxes, and Insurance, calculated on an annual basis.

Example:

  • Annualized Rents = $30,000
  • P.I.T.A. = $24,000

DSCR=30,000/24,000=1.25

Features of the Streamlined DSCR Approach:

Faster, simpler underwriting—ideal for smaller investors. Uses market rents or leases without requiring full expense breakdowns. Often allows minimum DSCRs as low as 1.0 for qualification, normally greater proceeds than the traditional DSCR approach. Recourse  SFR portfolios in the $2–$3 million range may even offer borrowers a choice between streamlined or traditional underwriting, based on lender guidelines and documentation provided.

Recourse vs. Non-Recourse Loans

An important difference between these two DSCR approaches is recourse:

  • Traditional Commercial DSCR Loans are typically non-recourse. This means the borrower’s liability is limited to the property itself. If the loan defaults, the lender can foreclose on the property but generally cannot pursue the borrower’s personal assets (except in cases of fraud or other “bad boy” carve-outs).
  • Streamlined DSCR Loans are typically recourse. The borrower signs a personal guarantee, making them responsible for any deficiency after foreclosure. If the property’s cash flow can’t cover the debt, the lender can pursue other personal assets or income to satisfy the debt.

Understanding the difference is critical when structuring deals and advising clients on their risk exposure.

Why the Difference?

  • Traditional Commercial Lending: Designed for large, complex properties where full NOI analysis is critical for risk assessment. Lenders relies on the cash flow of the property to support the loan repayment
  • Small-Balance/Private Lending: Built for efficiency and accessibility, prioritizing rent coverage over debt payments without extensive documentation. Lenders rely on the recourse provision and property cash flow o support the repayment of the loan.

Practical Implications for Borrowers

Understand your property’s cash flow under both methods. Expect lower DSCR minimums from private lenders—but often at higher rates or fees. Carefully weigh recourse vs. non-recourse exposure. Always budget for vacancies and expenses, even if your lender’s underwriting is simplified.

Why It Matters

Recourse vs. Non-Recourse:

  • Non-Recourse Loans (Traditional DSCR): Typically used for larger loan amounts (generally over $3 million) on properties like office buildings, industrial facilities, retail centers, multifamily complexes, build-to-rent communities, and larger SFR portfolios. These loans rely on the property’s cash flow to support repayment. If the borrower defaults, the lender can foreclose on the property but usually cannot pursue the borrower’s personal assets (except for specific “bad boy” carve-outs).
  • Recourse Loans (Streamlined DSCR): Common for smaller loan amounts (often under $3 million) on single-family rentals, 1–4 unit investment properties, small multifamily, smaller mixed-use, and SFR portfolios. These loans are personally guaranteed. If the property’s cash flow is insufficient, the borrower is responsible for covering any shortfall—even from personal assets.

Loan Proceeds Differences:

  • The streamlined approach often delivers higher loan proceeds relative to rents or property value, thanks to simplified underwriting focused on rent coverage and borrower guarantees.
  • The traditional approach may result in slightly lower proceeds, since it accounts for all operating expenses, reserves, and realistic income adjustments—ensuring truly sustainable cash flow.

Bottom line: Understanding these differences—recourse vs. non-recourse, loan amounts, property types, cash flow analysis, and proceeds—empowers borrowers and brokers to choose the right financing structure, manage risk, and secure the best possible terms for each deal.

Ready to take your commercial lending expertise to the next level?

At The Academy For Commercial Lending, we offer practical, expert-led training on DSCR loans, SBA programs, underwriting essentials, portfolio lending, and more. Whether you’re new to commercial mortgages or looking to deepen your knowledge, our courses are designed to help you advise your clients with confidence and close more deals.

Michael Boggiano, CPA CPM Experienced CRE Finance Professional | AI & Data Analytics Enthusiast | Championing Small Balance Commercial Lending

Learn more and enroll today!

Posted in blog and tagged , ,